
Mr. Van Wyck Brooks attempts to put a fresh spin on the serial killer genre, merely mostly serves up a bowl of soggy leftovers. While the way the film taps into the mind of a psychopath is apt, it has been done before (Ron Howard used a similar technique to enter the mind of John Ogden Nash in A Beautiful Mind). Still, this uneven, overstuffed movie does have entertainment value.
In Mr. Brooks, Kevin Costner is the title fibre, a reputable working form gent with a deep, dark secret. It seems that this respected menage man has something of a surprising hobby - he likes to hit people. He isn’t a killer for hire or anything like that. No, Mr. Van Wyck Brooks needs to kill to feel animated. It’s more than simple recreation - it’s an addiction.
Brooks is able to kick his awful habit cold turkey, just after several months on the big Dipper, his alter ego (played by a wonderfully eccentric William Bruise) attempts to nudge him back into his wacking ways. Reluctantly, Brooks agrees to take out some other unsuspecting victim, with the strict understanding that it is to be his last. Alas, a inept misstep during the title, threatens to destroy Mr. Brooks’ life for good. This particular misstep all but forces the lone hand to squad up with Mr. Captain John Smith (played by slacker comedian Dane Cook), a seamy photographer with a to the highest degree unusual request. Adding to the already thickened plot is a game of cat and mouse between Mr. Van Wyck Brooks and Spencer Tracy Altwood (played by Demi Moore), a police ship’s officer with some serious personal issues of her have.
Mr. Brooks starts cancelled interestingly sufficiency. The way the celluloid delves into the domestic life of this grim individual is interesting, and Costner is able to convey empathy. We never really hate this cat even though he’s fabulously disturbed and in desperate need of professional assist. The way director Bruce A. Evans gets inside this guy’s head is also interesting. Whenever Mr. Brooks is experiencing a psychotic bankrupt, it is manifest in the form of William Hurt. World Health Organization better to play the evil side of Kevin Costner than one of the greatest eccentric thespians of our time?
That Mr. Brooks really falls apart as a motion-picture show, can be blamed in large function on the convoluted morass of the screenplay. Kind of than simply focusing on Brooks’ unwellness, this film opts to go into far too many zany directions. There’s the Dane Cook scenario which is silly and utterly implausible. There’s the completely tiresome and unneeded sub plot of ground with Demi Moore and all her insignificant problems. And lastly, there’s a bizarre bit of business with Mr. Brooks’ college bound daughter that suggests perhaps the apple may not have fallen whatsoever too far from the tree. Spell these assorted plot duds ultimately cross, they experience more gimmicky than organic. What’s more, things feel far to a fault convienently pat.
Kevin Costner has ne’er been one of my favorite actors. I prefer Cosnter the director (with the exception of The Postman) to Costner the actor. As a performer, he picks great projects to be sure, merely his wearisome, mundane line delivery has always fazed me. There are exceptions. He has been rattling in a few stand out performances (see Silverado or Tin Cup), and it’s difficult to not get teary-eyed eyed when he plays catch with dear old dead dada at the end of Field of Dreams, simply ultimately, Costner is more than of a personality than an doer. With Mr. Brooks, he’s found a happy medium. He isn’t exactly brimfull with life here, but the thing is, his personality fits the quality. Mr. Brooks is a blase individual so it works.
William Hurt is spellbinding and he brings undeniable tension to the movie. This guy wants to be the dominant force in Mr. Brooks’ psyche and when Hurt is pushing buttons, the movie truly comes alive. Dane Cook is…Dane Cook. Zero more, nil less. Accuracy be told, I like this guy wire and hoped for more than out of him. Sadly, there’s no real depth here. I wasn’t fazed by his character’s want of motivation, I just never saw anything beyond Cook in a function. Having aforesaid that, Cook’s Mr. Smith is an absolute book of Revelation when curvaceous up against Demi Moore’s bland Tracy Altwood. I never bought into her tough as nails persona at all, and in fact, I found this turn so boring, that I was constantly rooting for Brooks to goal her piteous existence. Granted, it’s not entirely fair to find fault Moore. This character simply should feature been omitted from the screenplay only.
Mr. Van Wyck Brooks ends interestingly enough. During the last moments, in that location is a cheap shot scare, but what follows suggests that maybe we haven’t seen the end of this peculiar private, but more than importantly, we haven’t seen the last of his dark side. If Mr. Brooks returns, let’s hope the film maker’s focus on the title fiber rather than the uninteresting people about him.